Color Management in CS–Help!!!

TS
Posted By
Tim Smith
Mar 22, 2005
Views
391
Replies
7
Status
Closed
I’m a relatively novice PS user–in fact I started with CS. Am having a terrible problem printing color images using custom paper profiles. Here’s my setup:

Photoshop CS (8.0×119)
Mac G5 running OS X (10.3.8)
Epson 2200 printer
Apple Cinema Display monitor, calibrated using Monaco Optix Nikon D100, shooting raw images

I want to print on the 2200 using custom paper profiles, for example for Hahnemuhle rag papers. To debug things, I decided to use some of the Epson-supplied profiles for their papers, for example SP2200 EnhancedMatte 1440MK.icc. (I tried the Hahnemuhle profiles that I downloaded, and was having the same color problem, so I’ve reverted to the cheaper Epson papers for now until I get the problem solved.)

I’ve read the relevant stuff in the Photoshop CS manual, and the Classroom in a Book. I’ve also gone over the excellent tutorials on Ian Lyons computer-darkroom.com web site, and read a couple of postings by Bill Hilton on this site. The problem persists.

Basically, when I print using the Epson printer drivers, everything works just fine. But when I print (or even soft-proof) using a custom paper profile, I get that horrible magenta cast, that I’m told is typical of double color management (using both the paper .icc and the printer driver). Yet I’m pretty sure that I have turned the printer driver management off.

Here’s what I’ve done:

(1) Set up soft proofing for my paper profile, following Ian Lyon’s directions.
(2) Open my raw file, and import it into PS using camera raw. For these tests, I am making few or no adjustments in camera raw. (3) Adjust the image size.
(4) File–>Print with Preview
(5) Go to Page Setup to set the paper orientation and printer type. (6) In the Print dialog box, I set the source space to Document (Adobe RGB). (I’ve also tried my Proof setup–doesn’t matter in this case.) I then set the Print space to Profile: SP2200 EnhancedMatte 1440MK.icc, and the intent to relative colorimetric.
(7) I then go to Print, and
(8) set Color Management to Color Controls and Print Settings to the right media type, Advanced Settings (Photo – 1440dpi, and uncheck High Speed).
(9) At this point if i print (or even Preview), I get an image with a very pronounced magenta cast. Nothing subtle about it, it’s terrible.

Obviously, I’m either skipping a crucial step, or getting two settings into conflict.

Does anyone have any suggestions? I’ve been working on this for several weeks (keep coming back to it), and nothing I do seems to make any difference.

Long-winded message, I know, but thanks for any help.

Tim Smith

MacBook Pro 16” Mockups 🔥

– in 4 materials (clay versions included)

– 12 scenes

– 48 MacBook Pro 16″ mockups

– 6000 x 4500 px

N
nomail
Mar 22, 2005
Tim Smith wrote:

Here’s what I’ve done:

(1) Set up soft proofing for my paper profile, following Ian Lyon’s directions.
(2) Open my raw file, and import it into PS using camera raw. For these tests, I am making few or no adjustments in camera raw. (3) Adjust the image size.
(4) File–>Print with Preview
(5) Go to Page Setup to set the paper orientation and printer type. (6) In the Print dialog box, I set the source space to Document (Adobe RGB). (I’ve also tried my Proof setup–doesn’t matter in this case.) I then set the Print space to Profile: SP2200 EnhancedMatte 1440MK.icc, and the intent to relative colorimetric.
(7) I then go to Print, and
(8) set Color Management to Color Controls and Print Settings to the right media type, Advanced Settings (Photo – 1440dpi, and uncheck High Speed).
(9) At this point if i print (or even Preview), I get an image with a very pronounced magenta cast. Nothing subtle about it, it’s terrible.

Do NOT set the color management to "Color Controls", because that way you tell Photoshop to color manage and then you tell the printer driver to do it again (using Photo). Set this option to NO COLOR ADJUSTMENT.


Johan W. Elzenga johan<<at>>johanfoto.nl Editor / Photographer http://www.johanfoto.nl/
FH
Francois Hendrickx
Mar 22, 2005
Tim,

I have had the very same problem, with the very same cast. I struggled for a few months, then I had a few custom profiles made for the particular papers I want to use, and ever since, it’s sorted. Oh, and like Johan said, use "no color correction", that’s essential.

Cheers,

François

(9) At this point if i print (or even Preview), I get an image with a very pronounced magenta cast. Nothing subtle about it, it’s terrible.
J
Jim
Mar 22, 2005
"Tim Smith" wrote in message
I’m a relatively novice PS user–in fact I started with CS. Am having a terrible problem printing color images using custom paper profiles. Here’s my setup:

Photoshop CS (8.0×119)
Mac G5 running OS X (10.3.8)
Epson 2200 printer
Apple Cinema Display monitor, calibrated using Monaco Optix Nikon D100, shooting raw images

I want to print on the 2200 using custom paper profiles, for example for Hahnemuhle rag papers. To debug things, I decided to use some of the Epson-supplied profiles for their papers, for example SP2200 EnhancedMatte 1440MK.icc. (I tried the Hahnemuhle profiles that I downloaded, and was having the same color problem, so I’ve reverted to the cheaper Epson papers for now until I get the problem solved.)
I’ve read the relevant stuff in the Photoshop CS manual, and the Classroom in a Book. I’ve also gone over the excellent tutorials on Ian Lyons computer-darkroom.com web site, and read a couple of postings by Bill Hilton on this site. The problem persists.
Basically, when I print using the Epson printer drivers, everything works just fine. But when I print (or even soft-proof) using a custom paper profile, I get that horrible magenta cast, that I’m told is typical of double color management (using both the paper .icc and the printer driver). Yet I’m pretty sure that I have turned the printer driver management off.

Here’s what I’ve done:

(1) Set up soft proofing for my paper profile, following Ian Lyon’s directions.
(2) Open my raw file, and import it into PS using camera raw. For these tests, I am making few or no adjustments in camera raw. (3) Adjust the image size.
(4) File–>Print with Preview
(5) Go to Page Setup to set the paper orientation and printer type. (6) In the Print dialog box, I set the source space to Document (Adobe RGB). (I’ve also tried my Proof setup–doesn’t matter in this case.) I then set the Print space to Profile: SP2200 EnhancedMatte 1440MK.icc, and the intent to relative colorimetric.
(7) I then go to Print, and
(8) set Color Management to Color Controls and Print Settings to the right media type, Advanced Settings (Photo – 1440dpi, and uncheck High Speed).
(9) At this point if i print (or even Preview), I get an image with a very pronounced magenta cast. Nothing subtle about it, it’s terrible.
Obviously, I’m either skipping a crucial step, or getting two settings into conflict.
You may have thought that your turned the printer driver management off, but you are wrong. The proper setting is No Color Management. Jim
TS
Tim Smith
Mar 22, 2005
"Jim" wrote:

"Tim Smith" wrote in message

Basically, when I print using the Epson printer drivers, everything works just fine. But when I print (or even soft-proof) using a custom paper profile, I get that horrible magenta cast, that I’m told is typical of double color management (using both the paper .icc and the printer driver). Yet I’m pretty sure that I have turned the printer driver management off.

You may have thought that your turned the printer driver management off, but you are wrong. The proper setting is No Color Management.

You’re right, but I tried No Color Management, and I still get the same horrible magenta cast. I had tried that earlier, but forgot to mention it. I just tried it again, and still the same magenta. This one really has me scratching my head. I called a PS guru that I know, and he couldn’t solve it for me over the phone.

Is there some basic Preferences setting that I’ve mis-set? I’ve tried some things, but right now, due to my inexperience with PS, I’m just flailing around.

Tim Smith
J
Jim
Mar 23, 2005
"Tim Smith" wrote in message
"Jim" wrote:

"Tim Smith" wrote in message

Basically, when I print using the Epson printer drivers, everything works just fine. But when I print (or even soft-proof) using a custom paper profile, I get that horrible magenta cast, that I’m told is typical of double color management (using both the paper .icc and the printer driver). Yet I’m pretty sure that I have turned the printer driver management off.

You may have thought that your turned the printer driver management off,
but
you are wrong. The proper setting is No Color Management.

You’re right, but I tried No Color Management, and I still get the same horrible magenta cast. I had tried that earlier, but forgot to mention it. I just tried it again, and still the same magenta. This one really has me scratching my head. I called a PS guru that I know, and he couldn’t solve it for me over the phone.

Is there some basic Preferences setting that I’ve mis-set? I’ve tried some things, but right now, due to my inexperience with PS, I’m just flailing around.

Tim Smith
Perhaps you need to create a profile for your paper and your inks. That step cured a similar problem that I had with my 1280.
Jim
N
nomail
Mar 23, 2005
Tim Smith wrote:

I want to print on the 2200 using custom paper profiles, for example for Hahnemuhle rag papers. To debug things, I decided to use some of the Epson-supplied profiles for their papers, for example SP2200 EnhancedMatte 1440MK.icc. (I tried the Hahnemuhle profiles that I downloaded, and was having the same color problem, so I’ve reverted to the cheaper Epson papers for now until I get the problem solved.)
I’ve read the relevant stuff in the Photoshop CS manual, and the Classroom in a Book. I’ve also gone over the excellent tutorials on Ian Lyons computer-darkroom.com web site, and read a couple of postings by Bill Hilton on this site. The problem persists.
Basically, when I print using the Epson printer drivers, everything works just fine. But when I print (or even soft-proof) using a custom paper profile, I get that horrible magenta cast, that I’m told is typical of double color management (using both the paper .icc and the printer driver). Yet I’m pretty sure that I have turned the printer driver management off.

I’ve read you post again, and I notice two things. If you already see the cast in soft proof, it means the profile is wrong. Secondly, you mention a profile with ‘MK’ in the name. ‘MK’ stands for ‘Matt blacK’, meaning the matt black ink (rather than the normal photo black ink). Are you really using matt black ink? Finally, have to tried ‘Perceptual’ as intent?


Johan W. Elzenga johan<<at>>johanfoto.nl Editor / Photographer http://www.johanfoto.nl/
TS
Tim Smith
Mar 24, 2005
(Johan W. Elzenga) wrote:

Tim Smith wrote:

I want to print on the 2200 using custom paper profiles, for example for Hahnemuhle rag papers. To debug things, I decided to use some of the Epson-supplied profiles for their papers, for example SP2200 EnhancedMatte 1440MK.icc. (I tried the Hahnemuhle profiles that I downloaded, and was having the same color problem, so I’ve reverted to the cheaper Epson papers for now until I get the problem solved.)

I’ve read you post again, and I notice two things. If you already see the cast in soft proof, it means the profile is wrong. Secondly, you mention a profile with ‘MK’ in the name. ‘MK’ stands for ‘Matt blacK’, meaning the matt black ink (rather than the normal photo black ink). Are you really using matt black ink? Finally, have to tried ‘Perceptual’ as intent?

No, the profile is correct; I am using matte black ink. But a really strange thing happened. I went back to View–>Proof Setup–>Custom, and checked the Preserve Color Numbers check box, and all of a sudden everything started working for me.

To print normally, I can now use a Epson-supplied profile, and set the Source Space in the File–>Print with Preview–>Print dialog window to Document: Adobe RGB (1998), and the Print Space to Profile: SP2200 EnhancedMatte 1440MK.icc. I use Relative Colorimetric for the Intent, but the difference between that and Perceptual is minimal, for my images, at least.

(The difference between using the Epson-supplied "custom" 2200 profiles and the 2200 printer driver color management is minimal, just about nil. As one would expect. But later, I’ll be using supplied profiles from Hahnemuhle for their papers, and I wanted to make sure I could do this correctly.)

If I want to soft-proof, I set the Source Space to Proof: Proof Setup SP2200 EH 1440MK (my name for this custom proofing setup), and the soft proofing works OK too now.

But the soft-proof looks (and prints) very differently from the normal printing. A PS guru has told me that he finds this also, and doesn’t like the soft proofing very much.

Thanks to you and everyone else who reponded for your help. I think I’m at least on the right track now.

Tim Smith

How to Master Sharpening in Photoshop

Give your photos a professional finish with sharpening in Photoshop. Learn to enhance details, create contrast, and prepare your images for print, web, and social media.

Related Discussion Topics

Nice and short text about related topics in discussion sections