Which tablet with a 21" monitor?

R
Posted By
Robi
Apr 23, 2007
Views
514
Replies
10
Status
Closed
Hi,
I’m considering buying a tablet because Photoshop is sooo incomplete without it (I really miss a good brushing input device) and I wonder which tablet size should I choose.

I’m using a 21" monitor at 1600×1280 resolution, that feeds me with plenty of space for drawing, but I don’t know if that big size does influence the tablet dimensions too. Do you think buying a small A5 Wacom Graphire would be enough? Should I step up to a A4 tablet without even considering the A5 format?
Any suggestion?

I’m also used to turn on my secondary display for placing Photoshop’s tools and palettes aside, so that the entire 21" primary monitor space is available for drawing; how will the tablet work when switching the 2nd monitor on? I did never used a tablet with such a configuration, what do I have to expect from that? How will that work?

thanks,
Roberto

Must-have mockup pack for every graphic designer 🔥🔥🔥

Easy-to-use drag-n-drop Photoshop scene creator with more than 2800 items.

MM
Mister Max
Apr 23, 2007
Robi posted:

Hi,
I’m considering buying a tablet because Photoshop is sooo incomplete without it (I really miss a good brushing input device) and I wonder which tablet size should I choose.

I’m using a 21" monitor at 1600×1280 resolution, that feeds me with plenty of space for drawing, but I don’t know if that big size does influence the tablet dimensions too. Do you think buying a small A5 Wacom Graphire would be enough? Should I step up to a A4 tablet without even considering the A5 format?
Any suggestion?

I’m also used to turn on my secondary display for placing Photoshop’s tools and palettes aside, so that the entire 21" primary monitor space is available for drawing; how will the tablet work when switching the 2nd monitor on? I did never used a tablet with such a configuration, what do I have to expect from that? How will that work?

I use a Wacom tablet with two 21" monitors. It works fine, and has the advantage of allowing me to use two mice – one with the tablet, the other direct – which allows me to distribute my mouse work to both hands.

I use a small Wacom Graphire tablet, about 7 inches square, but don’t do much drawing with it, so can’t give good advice on the best size for you. – Max

MisterMax

Last few days of the solo show of my photos at the Burrison Gallery: The University Club at The Inn at Penn
2nd Floor, 3611 Walnut St, Philadelphia
March 26 to April 27 — Mon-Fri 8-6, Sat-Sun 7-1
..
Travel photos: http://buten.net/max
More photos: http://pbase.com/mistermax
W
wayne
Apr 24, 2007
In my experience it is more a matter of your personal approach than monitor size. Some people like large, gestural moements and others smaller ones. I use a 5×7 Intuos 3 tablet with a dual monitor setup and it works great for me. I also have small 4×5 Graphire 2’s and 3’s on a number of other computers. I find these a bit small for my Photoshop work but I mainly use those as mouse replacements. My heavy PS work is on the Intuos.

Cheers,

Wayne

Wayne J. Cosshall
Publisher, The Digital ImageMaker, http://www.dimagemaker.com/ Blog http://www.digitalimagemakerworld.com/
Publisher, Experimental Digital Photography
http://www.experimentaldigitalphotography.com
Personal art site http://www.cosshall.com/

Robi wrote:
Hi,
I’m considering buying a tablet because Photoshop is sooo incomplete without it (I really miss a good brushing input device) and I wonder which tablet size should I choose.

I’m using a 21" monitor at 1600×1280 resolution, that feeds me with plenty of space for drawing, but I don’t know if that big size does influence the tablet dimensions too. Do you think buying a small A5 Wacom Graphire would be enough? Should I step up to a A4 tablet without even considering the A5 format?
Any suggestion?

I’m also used to turn on my secondary display for placing Photoshop’s tools and palettes aside, so that the entire 21" primary monitor space is available for drawing; how will the tablet work when switching the 2nd monitor on? I did never used a tablet with such a configuration, what do I have to expect from that? How will that work?

thanks,
Roberto
K
krash
Apr 24, 2007
I purchased a 6×11 wacom, works great, even though I am pretty new with it… kk

"Robi" wrote in message
Hi,
I’m considering buying a tablet because Photoshop is sooo incomplete without it (I really miss a good brushing input device) and I wonder which tablet size should I choose.

I’m using a 21" monitor at 1600×1280 resolution, that feeds me with plenty of space for drawing, but I don’t know if that big size does influence the tablet dimensions too. Do you think buying a small A5 Wacom Graphire would be enough? Should I step up to a A4 tablet without even considering the A5 format?
Any suggestion?

I’m also used to turn on my secondary display for placing Photoshop’s tools and palettes aside, so that the entire 21" primary monitor space is available for drawing; how will the tablet work when switching the 2nd monitor on? I did never used a tablet with such a configuration, what do I have to expect from that? How will that work?

thanks,
Roberto
R
Robi
Apr 24, 2007
I use a Wacom tablet with two 21" monitors. It works fine, and has the advantage of allowing me to use two mice – one with the tablet, the other direct – which allows me to distribute my mouse work to both hands.

How does the tablet work with two monitors? Does the tablet snsitive area split in two (one half for each monitor) or is there some function that recognizes the pointer going back and forth so that the tablet area is fully used for the each entire 21" monitor area?

Roberto
AM
Andrew Morton
Apr 24, 2007
Robi wrote:
I use a Wacom tablet with two 21" monitors. It works fine, and has the advantage of allowing me to use two mice – one with the tablet, the other direct – which allows me to distribute my mouse work to both hands.

How does the tablet work with two monitors? Does the tablet snsitive area split in two (one half for each monitor) or is there some function that recognizes the pointer going back and forth so that the tablet area is fully used for the each entire 21" monitor area?

You simply change the area of the tablet which maps to the screen, otherwise the aspect ratio you’re using for the pen doesn’t match the aspect ratio of the pointer motion on the screen – I have an A5 Wacom and two monitors, and I don’t use the top and bottom sixths (approximately) of the tablet.

Andrew
R
Robi
Apr 24, 2007
How does the tablet work with two monitors? Does the tablet snsitive area split in two (one half for each monitor) or is there some function that recognizes the pointer going back and forth so that the tablet area is fully used for the each entire 21" monitor area?

You simply change the area of the tablet which maps to the screen, otherwise the aspect ratio you’re using for the pen doesn’t match the aspect ratio of the pointer motion on the screen – I have an A5 Wacom and two monitors, and I don’t use the top and bottom sixths (approximately) of the tablet.

You mean you map a big rectangular portion of the tablet to both screens together so that moving the pen left on the tablet you point to the left monitor screen and when dragging the pen right on the tablet the pointer moves to the monitor positioned on the right, correct? That means the tablet resolution gets halved so that it accomodates the giantic screen area, and you loose part of the tablet area because of the screen ratio (having two screens side by side doubles the global aspect ratio of the mapped area). Is that correct?

Having a so huge area to map can lessen the tablet resolution to a point that becomes usefull to opt for a bigger tablet, or not?

Roberto
AM
Andrew Morton
Apr 24, 2007
Robi wrote:
How does the tablet work with two monitors? Does the tablet snsitive area split in two (one half for each monitor) or is there some function that recognizes the pointer going back and forth so that the tablet area is fully used for the each entire 21" monitor area?

You simply change the area of the tablet which maps to the screen, otherwise the aspect ratio you’re using for the pen doesn’t match the aspect ratio of the pointer motion on the screen – I have an A5 Wacom and two monitors, and I don’t use the top and bottom sixths (approximately) of the tablet.

You mean you map a big rectangular portion of the tablet to both screens together so that moving the pen left on the tablet you point to the left monitor screen and when dragging the pen right on the tablet the pointer moves to the monitor positioned on the right, correct? That means the tablet resolution gets halved so that it accomodates the giantic screen area, and you loose part of the tablet area because of the screen ratio (having two screens side by side doubles the global aspect ratio of the mapped area). Is that correct?

That’s it.

Having a so huge area to map can lessen the tablet resolution to a point that becomes usefull to opt for a bigger tablet, or not?

I don’t find it a problem; I have an Intuos 2, which has half the resolution of an Intuos 3. Even so, it’s still 1000 lines per cm, which is about 20,000 vertical lines mapping to 2304 horizontal screen pixels.

Andrew
R
Roberto
Apr 24, 2007
I would go with at least a 6×8 or maybe even the 6×11. The larger ones are nice but take up more space. The ones I mention provide a nice balance of pen and mouse movement with a reasonable price and desktop realestate consumtion. I would not however consider any other brand besides Wacom. The cheaper ones are just that cheap toys that have iffy support from a company that may not be around next week. Wacom is the leader for a reason.

=(8)
N
noone
Apr 25, 2007
In article ,
says…
Hi,
I’m considering buying a tablet because Photoshop is sooo incomplete without it (I really miss a good brushing input device) and I wonder which tablet size should I choose.

I’m using a 21" monitor at 1600×1280 resolution, that feeds me with plenty of space for drawing, but I don’t know if that big size does influence the tablet dimensions too. Do you think buying a small A5 Wacom Graphire would be enough? Should I step up to a A4 tablet without even considering the A5 format?
Any suggestion?

I’m also used to turn on my secondary display for placing Photoshop’s tools and palettes aside, so that the entire 21" primary monitor space is available for drawing; how will the tablet work when switching the 2nd monitor on? I did never used a tablet with such a configuration, what do I have to expect from that? How will that work?

thanks,
Roberto

Roberto,

Some time back, either Tacit, Edjh, or Mike Russell (sorry, I do not recall exactly who said it) summed it up nicely. If you draw with your arm, a big tablet works great (provided you have the desktop for it), but if you draw with your fingers, then the smaller ones are in order. I only knew that I loved my big tablets, and hated my smaller one, but did not know why. That explanation did the trick for me – I draw with my arm.

If possible, give a few sizes a try and see which you work with best. It is more a matter of how YOU do it, than the size/rez of your monitor.

Hunt
R
Robi
May 29, 2007
I ended up buying a very cheap used A6 sized Wacom tablet and I’m pretty happy with that. It’s a good start, it’s a new world 🙂 Painting/drawing with that one is much more easy and powerfull than doing it with the mouse. The Wacom tablet, though being a very old model, provides me such a freedom I’d never expected. And the size is not a problem to me, even with that big 21" full screen size; I find that confortable.

Thank you for all of your suggestions.
Roberto

MacBook Pro 16” Mockups 🔥

– in 4 materials (clay versions included)

– 12 scenes

– 48 MacBook Pro 16″ mockups

– 6000 x 4500 px

Related Discussion Topics

Nice and short text about related topics in discussion sections