Why Maxtor 160GB is only 131069MB?

GM
Posted By
Graham Millington
Jun 26, 2003
Views
365
Replies
2
Status
Closed
"cpliu" wrote in message
I don’t understand how they calculate the size but it should be only called like 145GB than 160GB.

From Partition Magic, I can see

Western Digial 120GB = 114470MB
Iomega 120GB = 117796MB
Maxtor 160GB = 131069MB

No matter you divide it by 1024 or 1000, Maxtor exaggerates their size too much.

I have a WD 250GB drive and Windows (XP, NTFS) shows it as 250,056,704,000 bytes. The summary line in Explorer declares that this is between 232GB and 233GB, however.

Dividing by 1024 doesn’t help because (I believe) many manufacturers’ calculations assume that 1K is 1000bytes, that 1M is 1,000K and that 1G is 1,000M. Windows, however, assumes that 1GB is 1024 * 1024 * 1024 bytes. So perhaps one needs to divide by 1024 to the power of 3 (1,073,741,824) to get the formatted size recorded in Windows.

Master Retouching Hair

Learn how to rescue details, remove flyaways, add volume, and enhance the definition of hair in any photo. We break down every tool and technique in Photoshop to get picture-perfect hair, every time.

R
rtr
Jun 26, 2003
Another factor is many of the reports are "available space", that is after portions of the drive are set aside for housekeeping functions.

rtr

"cpliu" wrote in message
I don’t understand how they calculate the size but it should be only called like 145GB than 160GB.

From Partition Magic, I can see

Western Digial 120GB = 114470MB
Iomega 120GB = 117796MB
Maxtor 160GB = 131069MB

No matter you divide it by 1024 or 1000, Maxtor exaggerates their size too much.

A B
==============================
WD 120GB 95.39% 93.16%
Iomega 120GB 98.16% 95.86%
Maxtor 160GB 81.92% 80.00%

A – percentage of the actual size from claimed size based 1GB = 1000MB B – percentage of the actual size from claimed size based 1GB = 1024MB
Isn’t 80% too much? almost like fraud to me!

Any explanations??? Is it the same with WD or other brands?
BTW, I’m using NTFS on all of them.

cpliu

C
cpliu
Jun 26, 2003
I’m sorry that I accidentally post the question to the wrong group, but I’m grateful for getting 2 responses. Looks like I should call Maxtor to figure out if it’s a problem of my mainboard ( ASUS P4B266 ). Thanks for sharing your experience…

Best regards,

cpliu

How to Improve Photoshop Performance

Learn how to optimize Photoshop for maximum speed, troubleshoot common issues, and keep your projects organized so that you can work faster than ever before!

Related Discussion Topics

Nice and short text about related topics in discussion sections