Flatbed Scanners

D
Posted By
Deadlegs
Mar 16, 2005
Views
291
Replies
8
Status
Closed
I am overwhelmed by the choice of Photo scanners. Most photo scanners are coming with film and slide adpaters which I don’t require as I already have a dedicated film scanner. What are some opinions about the "best" flatbeds under the $1500 range.
Are there any good sites that provide multi supplier comparisons? Key criteria are that they should be capable of reproducing accurate colour, good shadow detail and most importantly decent scanning software.

Any advice will be appreciated.

Must-have mockup pack for every graphic designer 🔥🔥🔥

Easy-to-use drag-n-drop Photoshop scene creator with more than 2800 items.

R
Roberto
Mar 16, 2005
Epson. Stay away from HP. HP’s technology for their scanners and their printers including laser and inkjet is getting to the point it is very outdated. Epson in my opinion makes the best flatbed scanners.
C
Caitlin
Mar 16, 2005
"Deadlegs" wrote in message
I am overwhelmed by the choice of Photo scanners. Most photo scanners are coming with film and slide adpaters which I don’t require as I already have a dedicated film scanner. What are some opinions about the "best" flatbeds under the $1500 range.
Are there any good sites that provide multi supplier comparisons? Key criteria are that they should be capable of reproducing accurate colour, good shadow detail and most importantly decent scanning software.
Any advice will be appreciated.

Do scanners even come at that kind of price? You’ll get a top of the line Epson scanner for a lot less than that. But are you after a large format scanner? That’s a different ball game.
S
SCRUFF
Mar 17, 2005
"Caitlin" wrote in message
"Deadlegs" wrote in message
I am overwhelmed by the choice of Photo scanners. Most photo scanners are coming with film and slide adpaters which I don’t require as I already
have
a dedicated film scanner. What are some opinions about the "best"
flatbeds
under the $1500 range.
Are there any good sites that provide multi supplier comparisons? Key criteria are that they should be capable of reproducing accurate colour, good shadow detail and most importantly decent scanning
software.
Any advice will be appreciated.

Do scanners even come at that kind of price? You’ll get a top of the line Epson scanner for a lot less than that. But are you after a large format scanner? That’s a different ball game.

I bought a large format mustek a3 that is a total piece of junk. I’ve returned it twice but it still scans horribly. Avoid that one!
EG
Eric Gill
Mar 17, 2005
"Caitlin" wrote in
..au:

"Deadlegs" wrote in message
I am overwhelmed by the choice of Photo scanners. Most photo scanners are coming with film and slide adpaters which I don’t require as I already have a dedicated film scanner. What are some opinions about the "best" flatbeds under the $1500 range.
Are there any good sites that provide multi supplier comparisons? Key criteria are that they should be capable of reproducing accurate colour, good shadow detail and most importantly decent scanning software.

Any advice will be appreciated.

Do scanners even come at that kind of price?

Flatbeds range into the tens of thousands of dollars, bud. Maybe more – used to be, certainly, but I haven’t cheked in a few years.

You’ll get a top of the
line Epson scanner for a lot less than that. But are you after a large format scanner? That’s a different ball game.

There are a number of "normal" (roughly letter or legal) sized flatbeds that fall in between $450 and $1,500. UMAX has a half-dozen or so, as an example.

Whether any are worthwhile or not is another question entirely.
R
Rick
Mar 17, 2005
"Eric Gill" <
<snip>
| >
| > Do scanners even come at that kind of price?
|
| Flatbeds range into the tens of thousands of dollars, bud. Maybe more – | used to be, certainly, but I haven’t cheked in a few years. |
| > You’ll get a top of the
| > line Epson scanner for a lot less than that. But are you after a large | > format scanner? That’s a different ball game.
|
| There are a number of "normal" (roughly letter or legal) sized flatbeds | that fall in between $450 and $1,500. UMAX has a half-dozen or so, as an | example.
|
| Whether any are worthwhile or not is another question entirely.

We just tossed a bunch of not so old UMAX scanners. UMAX no longer produces those and there is ZERO support.
K
Kokoro
Mar 17, 2005
In alt.graphics.photoshop, Scruff ordered an army of hamsters to type:

I bought a large format mustek a3 that is a total piece of junk. I’ve returned it twice but it still scans horribly. Avoid that one!

Depends what you want. The Mustek A3 scanner is less than
D
Deadlegs
Mar 17, 2005
No, I have an HPSJ3C which can take legal sized documents which is ample fro my needs esp when most of my work is up to 8×10 photos.
"Caitlin" wrote in message
"Deadlegs" wrote in message
I am overwhelmed by the choice of Photo scanners. Most photo scanners are coming with film and slide adpaters which I don’t require as I already have a dedicated film scanner. What are some opinions about the "best" flatbeds under the $1500 range.
Are there any good sites that provide multi supplier comparisons? Key criteria are that they should be capable of reproducing accurate colour, good shadow detail and most importantly decent scanning software.
Any advice will be appreciated.

Do scanners even come at that kind of price? You’ll get a top of the line Epson scanner for a lot less than that. But are you after a large format scanner? That’s a different ball game.
S
SCRUFF
Mar 17, 2005
"Kokoro" wrote in message
In alt.graphics.photoshop, Scruff ordered an army of hamsters to type:
I bought a large format mustek a3 that is a total piece of junk. I’ve returned it twice but it still scans horribly. Avoid that one!

Depends what you want. The Mustek A3 scanner is less than

Must-have mockup pack for every graphic designer 🔥🔥🔥

Easy-to-use drag-n-drop Photoshop scene creator with more than 2800 items.

Related Discussion Topics

Nice and short text about related topics in discussion sections