Best film scanner for B&W?

LR
Posted By
Larry_RL
Nov 6, 2006
Views
300
Replies
8
Status
Closed
Just bought a Nikon SuperCoolScan 9000 ED, and while it does a good job on color negs and chromes, the B&W’s are terrible. There are some other irritating problems with this Nikon, such as the poor design of the 35mm film holders which allow the film to slide out of place during the preview, the lack of a "preview upon inserting the holder" option, changing to positive when you insert a negative, then displaying the negative as a negative, etc. Anyway, it’s going back and I’m still looking for a good film scanner. Any suggestions?

Must-have mockup pack for every graphic designer 🔥🔥🔥

Easy-to-use drag-n-drop Photoshop scene creator with more than 2800 items.

CC
Chris_Cox
Nov 6, 2006
Turn off the ICE and other corrections for B&W scans.
LR
Larry_RL
Nov 6, 2006
Yes, Chris, I did that but perfectly exposed B&W negatives have no detail in the lighter areas no matter what I do.
AC
Art Campbell
Nov 6, 2006
Before you take it back… take a look at/get VueScan at www.hamrick.com (also a good source of scanner info). It’s entirely possible that the bundled software isn’t optimized for what you need to do and/or the software doesn’t wring as much info out of the hardware as is possible.

Also, remember that you can set up your scans do use the HDR tools — merging three or more scans (way underexposed, normal, and way overexposed) to capture more detail than a single scan.

Art
PF
Peter_Figen
Nov 6, 2006
You have to dig into NikonScan’s preferences and reset the clipping values. The defaults clip the hell out of both highlights and shadows.
LH
Lawrence_Hudetz
Nov 6, 2006
Use the analog gain controls.
LR
Larry_RL
Nov 6, 2006
I must have a defective unit, which seems to be a problem for Nikon of late. Recently had to return two defective D200’s and a DX lens. A friend had to go through five DX2’s before finding one that did not have a defective sensor! This film slipping because there are no studs to lock in the sprocket holes has to be a defective film holder …the Nikon design team could not be that dumb…
LH
Lawrence_Hudetz
Nov 7, 2006
They are. 120 film has to be held in glass to keep sharp, therefore requiring anti-newton ring glass, of which the Nikon stuff is mediocre at best.
LR
Larry_RL
Nov 10, 2006
Found my scanner! It’s an Epson 750 M Pro. This thing will scan any film up to 8"x 10", and you can even do wet scans using Kami fluid! I haven’t tried the wet scan yet but, the B&W of a 120 neg is like being back under my Beselar!!! Oh yeah! This blows away the Nikon…

MacBook Pro 16” Mockups 🔥

– in 4 materials (clay versions included)

– 12 scenes

– 48 MacBook Pro 16″ mockups

– 6000 x 4500 px

Related Discussion Topics

Nice and short text about related topics in discussion sections