CS3 won’t automatically save file in same format as when opened

KA
Posted By
Ken_Albro
Aug 8, 2007
Views
431
Replies
7
Status
Closed
I am using Windows XP and when I open a file any formt, say .jpg for example.I make a few changes,click save, get a prompt "save changes to this document?". I click yes and get another box that defaults save in PSD format.
Since I opened a jpg file I now have to change it to save as jpg. I then click save and then have new dialog saying file already exists, and do I want to replace it? Then I click OK.
I have searched all the help files indicates that Photoshop"Save" command is supposed to save a file in the same format as when it was opened. That was the case for all prior versions of Photoshop that I have used. When I upgraded to CS3 I did not have this problem, one day it just started. I have deleted the Preferencs file. but no help.
What is going on?
I have 4 gig of ram, fast processor dual core
Any help will be appreciated.

/

MacBook Pro 16” Mockups 🔥

– in 4 materials (clay versions included)

– 12 scenes

– 48 MacBook Pro 16″ mockups

– 6000 x 4500 px

QP
Q_Photo
Aug 8, 2007
I’m not sure I understand correctly, but if you are trying to save a file as a jpg over and over you are causing damage to that file. Each time it is being compressed and losing more information. While editing it should be saved as a psd (or tif) until all work is completed. Then, and only then, you save it as a jpg.

Have you added layers or channels to these files? If so, they can’t be saved as jpg until image is flattened and extra channels deleted.

Q
KA
Ken_Albro
Aug 8, 2007
I am not saving the same JPG file. I am in the middle of updating myweb photo gallery so am working with a number of images.Below is a copy of the Photoshop help file that covers this.

"Saving and exporting images / Saving images
Save a file
You use the Save command to save changes to the current file or Save As to save a new version of the current file.

Save changes to the current file
Choose File > Save.
Save a file with a different name, location, or format
Choose File > Save As.

In the Save As dialog box, select saving options.
Click Save.
A dialog box appears for choosing options when saving in some image formats."

When I try to do a simple save based on the above help file statement, I should be able to open a file, make some changes and if I want the file to stay a JPG, I should be albe to click "save" and the file would close and no more dialog choices would pop up.In my case it is not doing that, it is making me manualy change from the default PSD to a JPG.

Ken
KA
Ken_Albro
Aug 8, 2007
I am not saving the same JPG file. I am in the middle of updating myweb photo gallery so am working with a number of images.Below is a copy of the Photoshop help file that covers this.

"Saving and exporting images / Saving images
Save a file
You use the Save command to save changes to the current file or Save As to save a new version of the current file.

Save changes to the current file
Choose File > Save.
Save a file with a different name, location, or format
Choose File > Save As.

In the Save As dialog box, select saving options.
Click Save.
A dialog box appears for choosing options when saving in some image formats."

When I try to do a simple save based on the above help file statement, I should be able to open a file, make some changes and if I want the file to stay a JPG, I should be albe to click "save" and the file would close and no more dialog choices would pop up.In my case it is not doing that, it is making me manualy change from the default PSD to a JPG.
KA
Ken_Albro
Aug 8, 2007
I just discovered somthing very important.I trying to trougleshoot and tried another file. opened new file tried a tff this time and did some work on it, went to Edit menu, selected "Save" and then noticed that the dialog box that opened was the
"Save As" dialog. there must be some real problems if I can’t get the "Save" to work right. There should not be anything to open, the save takes place and the file is closed.. I will have to call technical support.
JJ
John_Joslin
Aug 9, 2007
I have noticed this too.

For my work it it a minor annoyance but I can imagine for some it is an extremely irritating "feature".
C
chrisjbirchall
Aug 9, 2007
opened new file tried a tff this time and did some work on it, went to Edit menu, selected "Save" and then noticed that the dialog box that opened was the "Save As" dialog.

Doesn’t work like that here. Might I suggest resetting the preferences file. You’ll find details of "How To" in the FAQs.
BD
Brett Dalton
Aug 10, 2007
if you open a file type that supports layers and you add a layer it will default to PSD. Tiffs support layers so it can save the data. Try Flattening your file before saving it should default to Jpg.

BRETT

Master Retouching Hair

Learn how to rescue details, remove flyaways, add volume, and enhance the definition of hair in any photo. We break down every tool and technique in Photoshop to get picture-perfect hair, every time.

Related Discussion Topics

Nice and short text about related topics in discussion sections