Standard toolbar in Photoshop

G
Posted By
gtfacct
Apr 9, 2008
Views
703
Replies
16
Status
Closed
Hi all,

I saw a few threads previously generated on this, and I wanted to emphasize it once more:

I saw that a similar message was posted in 2002. Now it’s 2008, and I am having the same problem!

It’s ridiculous to port a software like this, and with this price, to Windows environment, and not incorporate standard-of-the-industry stuff, like a "Standard" toolbar with open, new, cut, copy, paste etc. Photoshop has all these ‘Workspaces’, and NONE of them have such a toolbar. I also could not find a way of creating a custom toolbar into which I can add these icons.

I was happily using Corel since version 3, and was recently "forced" to use Photoshop at work. It’s all coming back to me why I never got into Adobe products: They look and act like Apple (Mac) software, even if you have the windows version, and it’s anything but intuitive to use for a veteran windows user.

It’s a shame really, since I believe that more windows users would be willing to use Photoshop, if it was more "windows-user" friendly.

Now, the real question: Are there any plugins that plug this large hole?

Thanks.

Must-have mockup pack for every graphic designer 🔥🔥🔥

Easy-to-use drag-n-drop Photoshop scene creator with more than 2800 items.

G
gowanoh
Apr 9, 2008
What you talkin bout?
The top menu bar on CS3 conforms to Windows standards.
If you want to see a horrible non-standard mess take a look at Office 2007: my nominee for the worst user interface ever created for any program ever. Microsoft tossed away over 15 years of a stable interface design for this monstrosity. Of course, Microsoft also put out Vista, which explains alot. Yes, Adobe has a solid core of Macmorons.These people still are inordinately represented in the media perpetrating misinformation about color management and user interface (as if CS3 is a different program, apart from the idiosyncratic Mac keyboard commands, on the Mac).
However it has been reported that due to the unstable, proprietary development platform mess that is the Mac OS even Adobe is not preparing 64 bit CS4 for the Mac OS.
Finalmente, I used Corel Photopaint for a few years: Photoshop, arcane as it can be, is a breath of clarity by comparison.
TK
Toobi-Won Kenobi
Apr 9, 2008
wrote in message
Hi all,

I saw a few threads previously generated on this, and I wanted to emphasize it once more:

I saw that a similar message was posted in 2002. Now it’s 2008, and I am having the same problem!

It’s ridiculous to port a software like this, and with this price, to Windows environment, and not incorporate standard-of-the-industry stuff, like a "Standard" toolbar with open, new, cut, copy, paste etc. Photoshop has all these ‘Workspaces’, and NONE of them have such a toolbar. I also could not find a way of creating a custom toolbar into which I can add these icons.

I was happily using Corel since version 3, and was recently "forced" to use Photoshop at work. It’s all coming back to me why I never got into Adobe products: They look and act like Apple (Mac) software, even if you have the windows version, and it’s anything but intuitive to use for a veteran windows user.

It’s a shame really, since I believe that more windows users would be willing to use Photoshop, if it was more "windows-user" friendly.
Now, the real question: Are there any plugins that plug this large hole?

Thanks.
All these operations are easily carried out via keyboard shortcuts and I would think that it would be second nature to a "veteran" windows user. Taking your hands off the keyboard to carry out such simple tasks only slows you down.
I have used a "windows" version of PS since 1996 and have never found the lack of what you seek a problem.
TWK
G
gtfacct
Apr 9, 2008
On Apr 9, 12:03 pm, "Toobi-Won Kenobi" <Toobi-won > wrote:
All these operations are easily carried out via keyboard shortcuts and I would think that it would be second nature to a "veteran" windows user. Taking your hands off the keyboard to carry out such simple tasks only slows you down.
I have used a "windows" version of PS since 1996 and have never found the lack of what you seek a problem.
TWK

This is the disadvantage of posting for help into a fan-forum: Instead of helpful advice and objective comments, you get flamed. FYI, one individual’s personal experience and needs does not change the consensus. In windows environment, a standard toolbar is called as is for a reason. Sometimes, convenience, intuition and speed may not be mutually existent.

Now, anyone with a real answer to my question?

Thanks.
C
Celcius
Apr 9, 2008
wrote in message
On Apr 9, 12:03 pm, "Toobi-Won Kenobi" <Toobi-won > wrote:
All these operations are easily carried out via keyboard shortcuts and I would think that it would be second nature to a "veteran" windows user. Taking your hands off the keyboard to carry out such simple tasks only slows
you down.
I have used a "windows" version of PS since 1996 and have never found the lack of what you seek a problem.
TWK

This is the disadvantage of posting for help into a fan-forum: Instead of helpful advice and objective comments, you get flamed. FYI, one individual’s personal experience and needs does not change the consensus. In windows environment, a standard toolbar is called as is for a reason. Sometimes, convenience, intuition and speed may not be mutually existent.

Now, anyone with a real answer to my question?

Thanks.

I’m afraid Toobi’s answer is real. Even with Windows, I use keyboard shortcuts. It’s much faster.
However, Photoshop has fine tools in the form of "palettes" that you can dock to the toolbar or the side. These palettes allow you to make loads of changes. Personally, I use the layers palette a lot as well as the "info" and "actions"…
Another thing, the toolbar looks deceptively simple, but incorporates a lot of possibilities.
Toobi is not flaming you. Perhaps you’re new to Photoshop, but you’ll see, it’ll grow on you if you’re open to it.
Take care,
Marcel
TK
Toobi-Won Kenobi
Apr 9, 2008
wrote in message
On Apr 9, 12:03 pm, "Toobi-Won Kenobi" <Toobi-won > wrote:
All these operations are easily carried out via keyboard shortcuts and I would think that it would be second nature to a "veteran" windows user. Taking your hands off the keyboard to carry out such simple tasks only slows
you down.
I have used a "windows" version of PS since 1996 and have never found the lack of what you seek a problem.
TWK

This is the disadvantage of posting for help into a fan-forum: Instead of helpful advice and objective comments, you get flamed. FYI, one individual’s personal experience and needs does not change the consensus. In windows environment, a standard toolbar is called as is for a reason. Sometimes, convenience, intuition and speed may not be mutually existent.

Now, anyone with a real answer to my question?

Thanks.

Flamed?
If I have flamed you, you are the first one I have ever flamed!

You need to get out more!

TWK
TK
Toobi-Won Kenobi
Apr 9, 2008
Original Message —–
From: "GT-Force"
To: "’Mike Hyndman’"
Sent: Wednesday, April 09, 2008 10:29 PM
Subject: RE: Standard toolbar in Photoshop

Flamed?
If I have flamed you, you are the first one I have ever flamed!

So, saying "I would think that it would be second nature to a "veteran" windows user." Is not a suggestive and arrogant flaming statement on your part then.

You need to get out more!

See, you did it again! This is flaming, since it’s a personal insult statement. Keep your irrelevant personal comments to your personal self please, since I certainly do not need them. Post only relevant info in a forum or discussioun group (you need to read the etiquette apparently).
GT
Veteran Windows user was your description not mine, the quotation marks were.
As a veteran, I would have thought you would be aware of the following Windows (not Photoshop BTW)shortcuts:
Ctrl+O Open File
Ctrl+N New File
Ctrl+C Copy Selection
Ctrl+V Paste Selection
Ctrl+X Cut Selection.
Should I continue?

These are just a few of the myriad KB shortcuts available in Photoshop (and Windows since version 2 (1987))
Also, where I come from "you need to get out more" is an observation, certainly not an insult.
I can do insults if you prefer.
If you want to see real flaming, post your question in
alt.graphics.photoshop or the Adobeforums.
I wasn’t aware that usenet (it is a Newsgroup BTW, not a forum or discussion group) had an etiquette/code of conduct.

TWK
G
gtfacct
Apr 10, 2008
ok, let’s try this again. I’ll simplify my question trying to clarify it, so that, I may get an answer:

Is there a Photoshop plugin that adds a "Standard toolbar" to Photoshop CS3?

Thank you.

GT
JH
Juergen Heinzl
Apr 10, 2008
schrieb:
ok, let’s try this again. I’ll simplify my question trying to clarify it, so that, I may get an answer:

Is there a Photoshop plugin that adds a "Standard toolbar" to Photoshop CS3?

Perhaps you can find something here http://www.pluginsworld.com/ though I do must admit to consider your posting a wee bit unpolite as this neither is a fan forum nor seem you to know what being flamed really looks like.

Oh and never mind but your ‘feeling forced’ to use Photoshop may be your bigger problem here, really and given Adobe has published previews of PS the lack of a ‘standard toolbar’ may simply mean there hasn’t been any remarkable demand for something like that within the last 6 years in the first place.

Personally and only being an amateur photographer & PS CS2/3 user I’ve neither ever missed nor ever heard of such a plugin either, though 8-}

Cheers,
Juergen


I’ve got nothing to hide, but I’ve got nothing to share either.
C
Celcius
Apr 10, 2008
wrote in message
ok, let’s try this again. I’ll simplify my question trying to clarify it, so that, I may get an answer:

Is there a Photoshop plugin that adds a "Standard toolbar" to Photoshop CS3?

Thank you.

GT

To my knowledge, frankly no.
My last program, many years ago was Corel Draw. When I installed it, I used it as it was.
When I came to Photoshop, I adopted the approach native to Photoshop. Sorry,
Marcel
B
Boskey
Apr 10, 2008
wrote in message
Hi all,

I saw a few threads previously generated on this, and I wanted to emphasize it once more:

I saw that a similar message was posted in 2002. Now it’s 2008, and I am having the same problem!

It’s ridiculous to port a software like this, and with this price, to Windows environment, and not incorporate standard-of-the-industry stuff, like a "Standard" toolbar with open, new, cut, copy, paste etc. Photoshop has all these ‘Workspaces’, and NONE of them have such a toolbar. I also could not find a way of creating a custom toolbar into which I can add these icons.

I was happily using Corel since version 3, and was recently "forced" to use Photoshop at work. It’s all coming back to me why I never got into Adobe products: They look and act like Apple (Mac) software, even if you have the windows version, and it’s anything but intuitive to use for a veteran windows user.

It’s a shame really, since I believe that more windows users would be willing to use Photoshop, if it was more "windows-user" friendly.
Now, the real question: Are there any plugins that plug this large hole?

Thanks.

What in the world is your problem? Open up PS CS (any version) and across the top is a toolbar. Look closely, you will see file, edit, image, layer, select, filter, view, window, and help. These are in Windows type format. Click on any these headings and just like Windows, additional options appear. Now if you are confused between a toolbar and pallettes, try reading through the PS help pdf. Clicking on a pallette item changes the 2nd line of the tool bar to show options specific to that pallette action or item.

What the heck is "standard" these days anyway? I have Office 2007 and there is no standard one size fits all toolbar. Everything in the Office 2007 toolbars can be customized to fit the needs of the individual user, but no file-edit-view-tools-windows-help standard toolbar. I suppose "forced" learning of an application is difficult.
G
gtfacct
Apr 10, 2008
On Apr 10, 5:38 pm, "Boskey" wrote:
What in the world is your problem? Open up PS CS (any version) and across the top is a toolbar. Look closely, you will see file, edit, image, layer, select, filter, view, window, and help. These are in Windows type format. Click on any these headings and just like Windows, additional options appear. Now if you are confused between a toolbar and pallettes, try reading through the PS help pdf. Clicking on a pallette item changes the 2nd line of the tool bar to show options specific to that pallette action or item.

I’m not confusing anything here, but you seem to confuse a menu bar and a toolbar. Of course I know the pull-down menu bar exists, and what I was referring to is not that.

What the heck is "standard" these days anyway? I have Office 2007 and there is no standard one size fits all toolbar. Everything in the Office 2007 toolbars can be customized to fit the needs of the individual user, but no file-edit-view-tools-windows-help standard toolbar. I suppose "forced" learning of an application is difficult.

There are no toolbars in Office 2007, they are called ribbons.

I could not find a way of customizing toolbars in PS. Please let me know how, if it’s possible create a new toolbar, and add standard- toolbar butons, such as open, cut, copy, paste, save, onto this custom- toolbar.

Thanks again.
G
gtfacct
Apr 10, 2008
On Apr 10, 4:56 pm, Juergen Heinzl wrote:
Perhaps you can find something herehttp://www.pluginsworld.com/though Personally and only being an amateur photographer & PS CS2/3 user I’ve neither ever missed nor ever heard of such a plugin either, though 8-} Cheers,
Juergen

Thanks for you time and info, anyway.

GT
TK
Toobi-Won Kenobi
Apr 11, 2008
wrote in message
ok, let’s try this again. I’ll simplify my question trying to clarify it, so that, I may get an answer:

Are you suggesting that the contributors to this NG lack the intelligence to understand your question in its original format?
Why is that people like you, who are so quick to take offence in other’s postings, never see the problem in their own sarcastic posts?
Is there a Photoshop plugin that adds a "Standard toolbar" to Photoshop CS3?
If the lack of this feature is such an obstacle to your productivity, why don’t you toddle off to the PS Adobeforum, where you will find something called the "feature request list".
This is where the 24/7 PS power users highlight shortcomings or suggest improvements to the programme.
Here you will be able to list and request this obvious oversight in PS programming and have it considered, if deemed worthy, by the gods at Mount Adobe for inclusion in updates or future releases.
Just make sure you are wearing asbestos jockey shorts.
Sarcasm intended!
TWK
J
jd
Apr 11, 2008
Jeez guys lighten up.
Just because someone does things differently from you doesn’t make them smarter, dumber, better or worse. If you have a pointer for this guy, please post it, if not, please just keep quiet.

"pickled" wrote in message
What you talkin bout?
The top menu bar on CS3 conforms to Windows standards.
If you want to see a horrible non-standard mess take a look at Office 2007: my nominee for the worst user interface ever created for any program ever. Microsoft tossed away over 15 years of a stable interface design for this monstrosity. Of course, Microsoft also put out Vista, which explains alot.
Yes, Adobe has a solid core of Macmorons.These people still are inordinately represented in the media perpetrating misinformation about color management and user interface (as if CS3 is a different program, apart from the idiosyncratic Mac keyboard commands, on the Mac). However it has been reported that due to the unstable, proprietary development platform mess that is the Mac OS even Adobe is not preparing 64 bit CS4 for the Mac OS.
Finalmente, I used Corel Photopaint for a few years: Photoshop, arcane as it can be, is a breath of clarity by comparison.
TK
Toobi-Won Kenobi
Apr 11, 2008
"jd" wrote in message
Jeez guys lighten up.
Just because someone does things differently from you doesn’t make them smarter, dumber, better or worse. If you have a pointer for this guy, please post it, if not, please just keep quiet.

Who are you, a relative?
It’s is tone, notthequestion, that’s pissed me off big time!

TWK
"pickled" wrote in message
What you talkin bout?
The top menu bar on CS3 conforms to Windows standards.
If you want to see a horrible non-standard mess take a look at Office 2007: my nominee for the worst user interface ever created for any program ever. Microsoft tossed away over 15 years of a stable interface design for this monstrosity. Of course, Microsoft also put out Vista, which explains alot.
Yes, Adobe has a solid core of Macmorons.These people still are inordinately represented in the media perpetrating misinformation about color management and user interface (as if CS3 is a different program, apart from the idiosyncratic Mac keyboard commands, on the Mac). However it has been reported that due to the unstable, proprietary development platform mess that is the Mac OS even Adobe is not preparing 64 bit CS4 for the Mac OS.
Finalmente, I used Corel Photopaint for a few years: Photoshop, arcane as it can be, is a breath of clarity by comparison.

JH
Juergen Heinzl
Apr 11, 2008
schrieb:
[…]
I could not find a way of customizing toolbars in PS. Please let me know how, if it’s possible create a new toolbar, and add standard- toolbar butons, such as open, cut, copy, paste, save, onto this custom- toolbar.
[…]

Having got the German version so "my" menu item names are certainly different to "your" menu item names … try ALT+CTRL+SHIFT+M and ALT+CTRL+SHIFT+K.

Hope it helps,
Juergen


I’ve got nothing to hide, but I’ve got nothing to share either.

Master Retouching Hair

Learn how to rescue details, remove flyaways, add volume, and enhance the definition of hair in any photo. We break down every tool and technique in Photoshop to get picture-perfect hair, every time.

Related Discussion Topics

Nice and short text about related topics in discussion sections