CMYK grey vs. RGB grey

R
Posted By
replytonewsgrouponlyplease
Nov 8, 2003
Views
398
Replies
4
Status
Closed
Why is it if I desaturate an image in RGB then convert it to CMYK and desaturate it again it’s a different shade?

MacBook Pro 16” Mockups 🔥

– in 4 materials (clay versions included)

– 12 scenes

– 48 MacBook Pro 16″ mockups

– 6000 x 4500 px

F
Flycaster
Nov 8, 2003
"Dr. J. Smith" wrote in message
Why is it if I desaturate an image in RGB then convert it to CMYK and desaturate it again it’s a different shade?

Rounding errors would be my guess, given that many mode changes. Maybe someone else has a better explanation.

—–= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =—– http://www.newsfeeds.com – The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! —–== Over 100,000 Newsgroups – 19 Different Servers! =—–
S
Steve
Nov 8, 2003
methinks this happens with everything when converted….some just below our ability to detect – but shadows, my god!!! converting from RGB to CMYK, I have to reduce opacity to around 4% to be happy with the output.

just my 2cents worth 🙂

Steve

"Flycaster" wrote in message
"Dr. J. Smith" wrote in message
Why is it if I desaturate an image in RGB then convert it to CMYK and desaturate it again it’s a different shade?

Rounding errors would be my guess, given that many mode changes. Maybe someone else has a better explanation.

—–= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =—– http://www.newsfeeds.com – The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! —–== Over 100,000 Newsgroups – 19 Different Servers! =—–
MR
Mike Russell
Nov 8, 2003
Dr. J. Smith wrote:
Why is it if I desaturate an image in RGB then convert it to CMYK and desaturate it again it’s a different shade?

This turns out to be an interesting question, so the answer will be longer than the question by quite a bit 🙂

Desaturate uses mathmatics based on the HSL color space. HSL is defined geometrically in terms of RGB ratios.

For Hue/Sat/Lightness calculations, Photoshop treats a CMYK image as an RGB image, ignoring the K value. By this logic, when a CMYK image is desaturated, gray is generated by creating equal amounts of CMY inks. Since cyan is the weaker of the three inks, a desaturated CMYK image will take on a red cast.

One servicable work-around is to convert to an RGB working space for the desaturate operation, then back to CMYK afterward.

This quirk also affects the layer modes, the sponge tool, Image>Adjust>Variations, and Image>Adjust>Hue/Sat . For example a CMYK layer set to luminance mode will impart a red cast to the underlying layers. I recall reading that some of these operations have been changed in Photoshop CS, perhaps others will comment on this.



Mike Russell
http://www.curvemeister.com
http://www.zocalo.net/~mgr
http://geigy.2y.net
B
belowme
Nov 10, 2003
i’m gonna have to agree with you on this answer. the three colors mixed will create a muddy brown so a slight amount of black ink is added where the shadows are. rgb can be made up into millions of colors, cmyk is made up with 4 colors when printing presses print 4 colors they only buy 4 colors of ink that can be mixed in only one way to create black thats why when you convert to cmyk it changes slightly to exactly match what a printing press can recreate.
"Mike Russell" wrote in message
Dr. J. Smith wrote:
Why is it if I desaturate an image in RGB then convert it to CMYK and desaturate it again it’s a different shade?

This turns out to be an interesting question, so the answer will be longer than the question by quite a bit 🙂

Desaturate uses mathmatics based on the HSL color space. HSL is defined geometrically in terms of RGB ratios.

For Hue/Sat/Lightness calculations, Photoshop treats a CMYK image as an
RGB
image, ignoring the K value. By this logic, when a CMYK image is desaturated, gray is generated by creating equal amounts of CMY inks.
Since
cyan is the weaker of the three inks, a desaturated CMYK image will take
on
a red cast.

One servicable work-around is to convert to an RGB working space for the desaturate operation, then back to CMYK afterward.

This quirk also affects the layer modes, the sponge tool, Image>Adjust>Variations, and Image>Adjust>Hue/Sat . For example a CMYK layer set to luminance mode will impart a red cast to the underlying
layers.
I recall reading that some of these operations have been changed in Photoshop CS, perhaps others will comment on this.



Mike Russell
http://www.curvemeister.com
http://www.zocalo.net/~mgr
http://geigy.2y.net

Master Retouching Hair

Learn how to rescue details, remove flyaways, add volume, and enhance the definition of hair in any photo. We break down every tool and technique in Photoshop to get picture-perfect hair, every time.

Related Discussion Topics

Nice and short text about related topics in discussion sections