Does Elements have anything CS doesn’t?

DM
Posted By
dolce_man
Jul 9, 2004
Views
643
Replies
13
Status
Closed
Hi,

I just bought a Wacom tablet for some graphics classes. It came bundled with Elements 2.0, and although I already have CS installed, I was wondering whether there would be any benefit to installing Elements as well. I think I read that it takes some of PhotoShop’s more commonly used functions and makes them more easily accessible, and that it has some new features not available in CS. If this is not accurate or if it wouldn’t be worth installing it for some other reason, that’s fine, I’m just curious. I don’t use PhotoShop for anything on a professional level, just basic photo editing and amateur-ish graphics projects, at least for now 😉 Anyway, thanks for any feedback.

John

Must-have mockup pack for every graphic designer 🔥🔥🔥

Easy-to-use drag-n-drop Photoshop scene creator with more than 2800 items.

R
Roberto
Jul 9, 2004
Elements used to have quite a few things Photoshop didn’t, but with Photoshop CS that has changed. The only thing I can think of that Elements has that Photoshop CS doesn’t is recipes. Which I think are a waste of space, but then not being new to Photoshop may have something to do with that. Maybe if I was new they would be helpful <shrug>.

John

John Dolceamore wrote:
Hi,

I just bought a Wacom tablet for some graphics classes. It came bundled with Elements 2.0, and although I already have CS installed, I was wondering whether there would be any benefit to installing Elements as well. I think I read that it takes some of PhotoShop’s more commonly used functions and makes them more easily accessible, and that it has some new features not available in CS. If this is not accurate or if it wouldn’t be worth installing it for some other reason, that’s fine, I’m just curious. I don’t use PhotoShop for anything on a professional level, just basic photo editing and amateur-ish graphics projects, at least for now 😉 Anyway, thanks for any feedback.

John
MR
Mike Russell
Jul 9, 2004
John Dolceamore wrote:
Hi,

I just bought a Wacom tablet for some graphics classes. It came bundled with Elements 2.0, and although I already have CS installed, I was wondering whether there would be any benefit to installing Elements as well. I think I read that it takes some of PhotoShop’s more commonly used functions and makes them more easily accessible, and that it has some new features not available in CS. If this is not accurate or if it wouldn’t be worth installing it for some other reason, that’s fine, I’m just curious. I don’t use PhotoShop for anything on a professional level, just basic photo editing and amateur-ish graphics projects, at least for now 😉 Anyway, thanks for any feedback.

There are a couple of nice features in Elements, notably the selection brush, but the feature set is otherwise a subset of CS. Both of them support Curvemeister, so no problems there.

It does start considerably faster, though, and overall is a more user friendly program than the rather feature-rich Photoshop.

I’d recommend saving your copy of CS for a friend or relative. —

Mike Russell
www.geigy.2y.net
H
henrik2000
Jul 10, 2004
Elements only has the aforementioned recipes and other help funktions, too. Then it exclusively has the Quickfix contrast/color correction, a bundle of different correction tools all in one dialog, which is nice for beginners.
There are a few more contrast low key corrections implemented in a more convenient way than at Photoshop CS or Photoshop 7, where it is more technical/professional.Then again, Photoshop-CS-users might miss in Elements essentials like the curves or layer masks (but Elements offers clipping layers, which offer a workaround).
P
patrick
Jul 10, 2004
"John Dolceamore" wrote in message
Hi,

I just bought a Wacom tablet for some graphics classes. It came bundled with Elements 2.0, and although I already have CS installed, I was wondering whether there would be any benefit to installing Elements as well. I think I read that it takes some of PhotoShop’s more commonly used functions and makes them more easily accessible, and that it has some new features not available in CS. If this is not accurate or if it wouldn’t be worth installing it for some other reason, that’s fine, I’m just curious. I don’t use PhotoShop for anything on a professional level, just basic photo editing and amateur-ish graphics projects, at least for now 😉 Anyway, thanks for any feedback.

John
DM
dolce_man
Jul 10, 2004
Thank you all for the responses. I’ve read a little more about this Recipe feature, and I think it would come in handy for me. Are there any potential problems I should be worried about if I install Elements on a computer that already has CS? Will it try to overwrite any files or folders, or anything like that? Thanks 😉

John
JD
John Doe
Jul 11, 2004
Since Elements 2 is based on the Photoshop 7 engine you shouldn’t have any problems. Now Elements 3 when it comes it will be based on the CS engine which means you could have some problems. I know when Elements 1 came out it wouldn’t work with Photoshop 6 running and since they shared many of the same files, etc. I don’t know if they got that fixed or not. But, for now with what you have you shouldn’t have any problems.

John
H
henrik2000
Jul 11, 2004
Are there
any potential problems I should be worried about if I install Elements on a computer that already has CS? Will it try to overwrite any files or folders, or anything like that? Thanks 😉

Photoshop CS and Photoshop Elements 2 on the same PC is absolutely no problem. I’ve seen both on one machine, no problem. Generally I feel that Adobe does relatively hasslefree software including installation questions. Less problems than with other software makers.
DM
dolce_man
Jul 11, 2004
Cool, thanks for the info 😉

John

"John Doe" …
Since Elements 2 is based on the Photoshop 7 engine you shouldn’t have any problems. Now Elements 3 when it comes it will be based on the CS engine which means you could have some problems. I know when Elements 1 came out it wouldn’t work with Photoshop 6 running and since they shared many of the same files, etc. I don’t know if they got that fixed or not. But, for now with what you have you shouldn’t have any problems.

John
DM
dolce_man
Jul 12, 2004
(Henrik2000) wrote in message news:…
Are there
any potential problems I should be worried about if I install Elements on a computer that already has CS? Will it try to overwrite any files or folders, or anything like that? Thanks 😉

Photoshop CS and Photoshop Elements 2 on the same PC is absolutely no problem. I’ve seen both on one machine, no problem. Generally I feel that Adobe does relatively hasslefree software including installation questions. Less problems than with other software makers.

Thank you 😉

John
T
TooSano
Jul 12, 2004
I go back and forth from them both. On simple projects the elements magic wand seems to work a little better and it is much easier to remove color in elements, also. Obviously, you can achieve all of this in PS, but elements is just set up to be easier
for the beginner or less complicated work.

"Henrik2000" wrote in message
Are there
any potential problems I should be worried about if I install Elements on a computer that already has CS? Will it try to overwrite any files or folders, or anything like that? Thanks 😉

Photoshop CS and Photoshop Elements 2 on the same PC is absolutely no problem. I’ve seen both on one machine, no problem. Generally I feel that Adobe does relatively hasslefree software including installation questions. Less problems than with other software makers.
R
Rich
Jul 14, 2004
a nice cheep price tag. 🙂

www.digitalmood.co.uk

"John Dolceamore" wrote in message
Cool, thanks for the info 😉

John

"John Doe" wrote in message
news:<6o5Ic.1604$>…
Since Elements 2 is based on the Photoshop 7 engine you shouldn’t have
any
problems. Now Elements 3 when it comes it will be based on the CS engine which means you could have some problems. I know when Elements 1 came
out it
wouldn’t work with Photoshop 6 running and since they shared many of the same files, etc. I don’t know if they got that fixed or not. But, for
now
with what you have you shouldn’t have any problems.

John
CC
Chris Cox
Jul 19, 2004
In article <rYpHc.12967$>, Mike
Russell wrote:

John Dolceamore wrote:
Hi,

I just bought a Wacom tablet for some graphics classes. It came bundled with Elements 2.0, and although I already have CS installed, I was wondering whether there would be any benefit to installing Elements as well. I think I read that it takes some of PhotoShop’s more commonly used functions and makes them more easily accessible, and that it has some new features not available in CS. If this is not accurate or if it wouldn’t be worth installing it for some other reason, that’s fine, I’m just curious. I don’t use PhotoShop for anything on a professional level, just basic photo editing and amateur-ish graphics projects, at least for now 😉 Anyway, thanks for any feedback.

There are a couple of nice features in Elements, notably the selection brush, but the feature set is otherwise a subset of CS. Both of them support Curvemeister, so no problems there.

The Selection Brush is a subset of Quick Mask in Photoshop.

It does start considerably faster,

Actually, PS CS and Elements 2.0 launch in almost exactly the same amount of time (on the same system, with the same fonts, plugins, etc.).

Chris
A
adykes
Jul 19, 2004
In article ,
Henrik2000 wrote:
Are there
any potential problems I should be worried about if I install Elements on a computer that already has CS? Will it try to overwrite any files or folders, or anything like that? Thanks 😉

Photoshop CS and Photoshop Elements 2 on the same PC is absolutely no problem. I’ve seen both on one machine, no problem. Generally I feel that Adobe does relatively hasslefree software including installation questions. Less problems than with other software makers.

If you use the layers features in CS agressivly you can wind up with a much larger PSD file, which will be slow to load, and process on a marginal machine.


Al Dykes
———–
adykes at p a n i x . c o m

How to Master Sharpening in Photoshop

Give your photos a professional finish with sharpening in Photoshop. Learn to enhance details, create contrast, and prepare your images for print, web, and social media.

Related Discussion Topics

Nice and short text about related topics in discussion sections